What Should We Do About ICE? 

Once, in the days following the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks on the United States, a strengthened federal agency empowered to protect the country from alien threats to our people, our property, and our democracy seemed essential. 

That’s why Congress passed a 2002 law creating the Immigrations and Customs Enforcement agency in 2003. ICE reports to a parent, the Department of Homeland Security; acts as the investigative arm of DHS, and enforces immigration laws inside the country. A sibling agency, U.S. Customs and Border Protection, was created at the same time to keep ports of entry and land and sea borders secure.

Since the start of the second Trump administration in January 2025, the agencies have started acting with new urgency to carry out President Trump’s goal of cracking down on unauthorized immigration. Stalwart Make-America-Great-Again voters tend to like this objective. And Trump said federal agents would concentrate on going after migrants here unlawfully to commit violence and to deal drugs, “the worst of the worst.” 

That set the stage for highly visible “surges” of masked and armed federal agents into cities big and small, workplace raids, and aggressive traffic stops. There have been daily-arrest quotas scaled up and back down; and racial profiling of targets, based not on behavior but people’s appearances and discernable jobs, has been approved by the U.S. Supreme Court since August 2025.

The fear now, even if it is not fully explained in each conversation, is that an appearance from ICE can lead to a cascade of harm, even when unjustified.

In our video age, bystander images and other footage show misdeeds and overreaches occurring in multiple places. (See the chart below.) The public has seen the shootings, physical injuries, patterns of civil rights violations, victim-blaming perpetuated by ICE and DHS when someone is hurt; children detained and families separated; and small businesses shuttered when people are too afraid to come out of the house and go to work.

Calls for accountability and oversight seem to go unheeded.

Public opinion measured

A national poll of 1,600 U.S. citizens conducted by The Economist/YouGov Poll in late July found that 54% had either only a little confidence (11%) in ICE or none at all (42%).1 The polling organization said those surveyed indicated they were aware of recent fatal shootings involving ICE. 

One of the incidents centered on 25-year-old Joan Sebastian Duran Guerrero. He was killed in a small town in Maine, on July 13, 2026, by an ICE agent while he was driving to one of his two jobs. Duran Guerrero came upon ICE agents conducting a traffic stop and he tried to get away rather than interact. He was not actually an ICE target, the government admitted. 

Still, DHS said Guerrero had entered the country illegally and when he didn’t stop for ICE officers, one officer feared for “public safety” and opened fire.2 

Guerrero was a married dad with a toddler and a work permit. 

The officer worried about public safety was David Brouillette. Questions about him continue. He is twice divorced, also a father, and was discovered by the Associated Press to have a history of domestic violence reports shown in family court records from Maine.3 

Other issues turned up in  Brouillette’s record as well, such as having credibility issues when appearing in court.  Eventually, Tom Homan, the Trump administration’s “border czar,” admitted on television that Brouillette should not have made it through the hiring process.4

The case was similar in many ways to the July 7, 2026 shooting in Houston, where an ICE officer fatally shot homebuilder Lorenzo Salgado Araujo. He was not actually a DHS target. Araujo was driving himself and others to work at their construction jobs and he looked like someone the agency was trying to find, according to media reports.

DHS said the driver’s own conduct — allegedly ignoring officer commands and then trying to run over an ICE officer — prompted an agent to shoot in self-defense. The officer responsible for the shooting was not identified.5

When the respondents to The Economist/YouGov Poll opened their surveys, 60% said they had heard about these killings. Fifty-eight percent said ICE was using too much force in its operations. But opinions differ according to party affiliation: 91% of Democrats and 63% of independents said ICE had used too much force, compared to only 19% of Republicans.6  

Related Posts